Monday, October 31, 2011

Statement of Solidarity: Alaa Abd El Fattah Boycotts Military Trials

We, the Campaign to End the Military Trials of Civilians, condemn in the strongest possible terms the imprisonment of prominent Egyptian activist and blogger, Alaa Abd el Fattah and the unjust and illegal system of military tribunals implemented by the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF) since becoming rulers of Egypt on January the 28th, 2011.

Today Alaa Abd El Fattah was summoned to the Military Prosecutor's office, accused of assaulting military personnel, stealing and destroying military weaponry and inciting violence against the military in the events of 9 October at Maspero. On questioning, Abd El Fattah declined to answer the prosecutor’s questions, stating that it is illegal and a clear conflict of interest for the military, as a party accused of a crime in the same events, to hold proceedings or adjudicate fairly. He was sent to detention pending further military investigation. 

As of today we refuse to co-operate with the military prosecution of civilians and we call on all Egyptian citizens to stand with us. 

At least 12,000 Egyptian civilians have been subjected to summary, covert military trials. The accused are often denied counsel, the opportunity to review evidence or examine witnesses; there are limited avenues of appeal. Eighteen death sentences have been handed down so far. 

Abd El Fattah's targeting is only the latest  example of the systematic targeting of journalists, media figures, bloggers and activists by SCAF. 

Abd El Fattah is being held responsible for violence on October 9th, the night when the Army killed at least 28 peaceful protesters and injured several hundred more. Several respected human rights organisation have attested to this. 

Furthermore, it is perverse that Mina Daniel is listed as the first name on the Military Prosecutor's list of the accused. Mina Daniel was killed by military gunfire on October 9th. 

Abd El Fattah is now being held for fifteen days in prison by a body which has no legal authority to do so. The fifteen days can be renewed indefinitely. Twenty eight more people are in jail against the background of the same event. Mina Daniel and others have already paid with their lives.

We demand that Alaa Abd El Fattah be freed immediately, that military trials of civilians be stopped and all those sentenced thus far be released or, at least, retried before civilian courts. We support all of those who similarly refuse to recognize the legitimacy of the military prosecution.  

This is not the new Egypt we have fought and died for.

For more information please contact us at

Tuesday, October 25, 2011

Egypt: End Military Trials for Civilians


On becoming the de facto rulers of Egypt on January the 28th, the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF) instantly implemented an unjust and illegal system of military justice. Thousands of Egyptian civilians have been subjected to quick, covert trials in military courts, often without access to a lawyer, an opportunity to review the evidence against them, or to bring and examine witnesses, and with limited avenues of appeal.

The first trial and conviction of a civilian in a military court was on January 28. His name has still not been released. Since then nearly 12,000 have been tried, including several minors who have been given prison sentences to be served in adult prisons.

According to General Adel Morsy, head of the military court, 18 people have so far been sentenced to death.

[Figures: Human Rights Watch & No to Military Trials for Civilians]

This behaviour is in stark violation of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which obligates states to protect and ensure the right to fair trial and freedom of expression. Egypt is a signatory and SCAF vowed to uphold all of Egypt’s standing international obligations.

Human Rights Watch strongly opposes the military trial of civilians, stating:

“The proceedings do not protect basic due process rights and do not satisfy the requirements of independence and impartiality of courts of law. Defendants in Egyptian military courts usually do not have access to counsel of their own choosing and judges do not respect the rights of defense. Judges in the military justice system are military officers subject to a chain of command and therefore do not enjoy the independence to ignore instructions by superiors.”

As well as receiving extensive prison sentences, detainees have reported several serious violations of their human rights, including torture and forced virginity checks.


The systematic targeting of journalists, media figures, bloggers and activists by the Military Prosecutor shows a clear attempt to impose a new form of censorship on Egyptian citizens. High profile figures such as Reem Maged, prominent television journalist, and Hossam El Hamalawy, journalist and activist, have been summoned to the prosecutor simply for criticising the military police. Public pressure seemed to prevent further action being taken by the Prosecutor.

However, lesser known activists have been prosecuted and jailed. The most pressing example is Maikel Nabil, a blogger sentenced to three years for “insulting the military establishment” and “spreading false information” in a blog post entitled The People and the Army were Never One Hand. He is now entering his 63rd day of a hunger strike, demanding that he be tried by a civil court. On his re-trial on October 18th he was ordered to be transferred to a psychiatric hospital. Nabil has vowed he would rather die than submit to the inequity of the new regime of military justice.

If SCAF is not pressured into complying with their own human rights rhetoric, Nabil will surely soon be dead.


On October 9, army forces attacked a peaceful march demanding better protection for Egypt's minorities - the Coptic community in particular. At least 25 people were killed, mostly Christians, by military gunfire and by armoured personnel carriers, which drove through the crowds.

SCAF issued conflicting excuses and justifications for the killings, while avoiding culpability by placing blame on “foreign hands” and “instigators” and many demonstrators were also arrested and are now facing military trial.

Videos of the attack are collected here.

This marks a significant turning point in our ongoing revolution. Fair reportage of events has been suppressed, to the point that noted television host Yousri Fouda has suspended his show, The Last Word, in response to ongoing censorship exerted by SCAF. Similar pressures have been exerted on several television figures as the few remaining spaces for dissent are clamped down on.



Prominent bloggers Alaa Abd El Fattah and Bahaa Saber are summoned to the Military Prosecutors office. The probable charges are “incitement to violence and destruction of public property”.

This summons is a further example of SCAF’s crackdown. Abd El Fattah is a respected proponent of free speech and advocate for democratic rights, while Bahaa Saber is a similarly well known activist. Both already spent time in jail for their activism in 2006, while Saber was detained again in 2010 and tortured.


Essam Ali Atta, sentenced to three years by a military court for a "common crime", is tortured to death by police officers in Torah prison.

Military trials are for military offences committed by military personnel. These trials are a travesty of justice and a dishonour to the people who gave their lives to liberate Egypt. They must end now.


Bloggers Alaa Abd El Fattah was detained for 15 days pending investigation, after his refusal to respond to questions on the ground that the military court is an illegitimate authority and the military is itself accused of involvement in the recent violent events that took place at Maspero. Bahaa Saber was released on bail. For up-to-date information please see the twitter hashtag #freealaa.


Write to your congressman, senator or parliamentarian. One of the few areas that SCAF can be pressured is their dependance on American foreign aid.

Sign this online petition and join this FB group.

Post pictures of detainees on the walls of Egyptian embassies.

Prepare for a global day of action outside Egyptian embassies to protest SCAF’s hijacking of our popular revolution.


Dear ,

As a member of your electorate I urge you to make immediate statements and take immediate steps to voice your opposition to Egypt’s Supreme Council of the Armed Forces’ escalating crackdown on the legitimate right of Egyptian citizens to peaceful protest and free expression. Since January 2011, over 12,000 civilians have been subjected to speedy and unjust military trials - a form of justice widely condemned by international human rights organisations such as Amnesty and Human Rights Watch.

Our government must stand by its public statements and act to support the Egyptian people’s demands for their human rights and the rule of law.


Saturday, October 1, 2011

30/9 - List of those detained while demonstrating in front of the Ministry of Defence

The following people were detained and are currently being held at the Military Prosecution Facility C28:

  1. Khaled Saleh Omar
  2. Mostafa Abdel Raouf
  3. Ahmed Ali Ayman
  4. Mahmoud Hamdy
  5. Ahmed Ibrahim
  6. Yehia Ahmed
  7. Mohammed Emad
  8. Motaz Billah Osama
  9. Ali Mohsen
  10. Hani Ahmed
  11. Karim Samir
  12. Tarek Mohammed Saeed (currently at Military Investigations after being moved from C28).